The Sanctuary at Kiawah vs. The Dunlin Auberge: Which Resort is Better?

Two of the most talked-about luxury resorts near Charleston are about fifteen minutes apart, and I’ve stayed at both (more than once!). Charleston is home for us, so these are my go-to staycation spots, and I get asked all the time which one to book.

Here’s the thing: they’re totally different hotels. The Sanctuary at Kiawah Island is a classic, grand beach resort. The Dunlin, Auberge Resorts Collection is a dreamy little riverfront hideaway on the marsh. Both are gorgeous, and the right one depends on the trip you’re planning. Here’s my honest breakdown of each (and where I’d book!).

Which Setting is Better: Beachfront vs. Lowcountry Marsh

The Sanctuary sits right on Kiawah’s ten-mile beach. At low tide the sand is so wide and packed that you can ride bikes on it, the waves are gentle enough for little ones, and you smell the salt air (and a little pluff mud, iykyk) the second you walk out the back of the hotel. Lobby, pool deck, beach. That easy!

The Dunlin sits on the Kiawah River, about fifteen minutes inland from the beach. It’s gorgeous in its own way: spartina grass, live oaks dripping in Spanish moss, marsh views for days, and that dreamy Lowcountry stillness at golden hour. If a riverfront stay is what you’re after, The Dunlin does it so well. Just know you’ll be hopping in the car for beach days.

My take: I’m a beach girl through and through. Being on the sand a minute after leaving our room is my favorite thing, especially with the kids, and no marsh view can compete with that for me.

Winner for setting: The Sanctuary at Kiawah.

The Design and Vibe: Classic Southern vs. Modern Coastal

The Dunlin is SO pretty. Whitewashed cottages, breezy linens, soft layered neutrals… it looks like a Pinterest board came to life. Auberge always nails design, and Linnette’s (more on that below!) is one of the prettiest dining rooms anywhere near Charleston.

The Sanctuary is a completely different mood. It opened in 2004 and leans into classic Southern grandeur, with a sweeping staircase, big Lowcountry murals, lush gardens and a lobby that makes you stand up a little straighter when you walk in. It feels like a hotel that’s been the gold standard around here for twenty years, because it has!

My take: If your style is modern and design-y, you’ll fall for The Dunlin. If you love grand, timeless interiors, The Sanctuary is your spot.

Winner for atmosphere: Totally a taste thing! Traditional and grand: The Sanctuary. Modern and curated: The Dunlin.

The Service: Polished vs. Laid-Back

Service is a big one for me when I’m spending real money on a hotel. The Sanctuary has had twenty-plus years to fine-tune everything, and you feel it the moment you pull up. The beach attendants have your chairs set up before you walk down, the pool servers remember your drink order by day two, and the bellmen know your name. Everything just runs.

The Dunlin’s service feels more relaxed and easygoing. The team is so warm and friendly, and staying there feels a little like visiting a friend’s (very chic) river house. Lots of people love that laid-back vibe, especially on a couples trip or a girls’ weekend!

My take: I’m a sucker for that polished, anticipate-everything style of service, so The Sanctuary wins for me. If you’d rather things feel casual and unfussy, you might love The Dunlin’s style more.

Winner for service: The Sanctuary if you love polished and buttoned-up. The Dunlin if you love warm and laid-back.

The Activities: Full Beach Resort vs. Quiet Nature Retreat

Staying at The Sanctuary gets you the whole Kiawah Island Golf Resort world: five championship golf courses (the Ocean Course, Turtle Point, Osprey Point, Cougar Point, and Oak Point on Johns Island), multiple pools, tennis, the spa, miles of bike paths through the maritime forest, and of course the beach. You could easily fill a week.

The Dunlin is all about slowing down. Think kayaking and paddleboarding on the river, birdwatching, marsh tours, farm-to-table experiences, and access to the Spring House, the Kiawah River community’s pool and fitness spot. If your idea of vacation is unplugging and getting out on the water, you’ll love it here.

Winner for activities: The Sanctuary if you want lots to do. The Dunlin if you want that dreamy, Where-the-Crawdads-Sing Lowcountry vibe.

Who You’ll See There

The Sanctuary is a family resort with a big golf crowd. Lots of multigenerational trips (babies to grandparents!) and East Coast regulars who come back every summer, all in resort wear, golf clothes or workout gear. Even on busy weekends the adult pool never felt crowded, and there’s a separate family pool, so you’re not dodging floaties while you read your book.

The Dunlin is more of a couples and girls’ weekend spot. Think cute Southern sundresses at lunch, friends driving down from Charleston for brunch, and long pre-dinner drinks on the porch. It feels like a grown-up getaway, and the whole property is set up for exactly that.

Which Resort Is Best for Families?

For a family trip, I’d pick The Sanctuary every time.

The beach is the biggest reason. Toddlers and the ocean are just a better combo than toddlers and a river! The pools are big and kid-friendly (including a dedicated family pool), the bike paths on the island are flat and safe, and Kamp Kiawah, the resort’s kids’ program for ages 3 to 7 (plus Camp Xtreme for ages 8 to 13), is one of the best-run kids’ clubs I’ve seen anywhere on the East Coast.

The Dunlin is a small property, with 72 cottage-style rooms and 19 villas, a pool and access to the Spring House. It’s lovely, but it’s really made with adults in mind. In July and August the river can also get pretty hot and buggy, and you don’t get that Atlantic breeze you have at The Sanctuary.

Winner for families: The Sanctuary at Kiawah.

The Dining

Linnette’s at The Dunlin is the sleeper hit here. The dining room is stunning (second floor, marsh views, all that soft Lowcountry light), the menu is seasonal and seafood-heavy, and Executive Chef Michael DeCicco spent years in Thomas Keller’s kitchens, including The Surf Club in Surfside, where he helped earn the restaurant its first Michelin star. Get the crab Caesar and the cornbread skillet! Both are worth the drive even if you’re not staying there.

The Sanctuary gives you lots of options. The Ocean Room is the signature steakhouse with one of the best wine lists in the Lowcountry, Jasmine Porch does Southern coastal classics, The Beach Club is your easy poolside lunch, and Cherrywood BBQ and Ale House is over at the golf clubhouse. The rest of Kiawah’s restaurants are a quick bike or golf cart ride away, too.

Insider tip on Club Level at The Sanctuary: If you’re debating an upgrade, this is the one I’d do. Club Level gets you a private lounge with complimentary breakfast, lunch and dinner, plus afternoon hors d’oeuvres, evening cocktails and desserts. With kids it’s so nice not having to plan meals around pool and beach time, and it pretty much pays for itself.

My take: Linnette’s is 100% worth a meal if you’re in the area. But Charleston has some of the best restaurants in the country, so I always plan a couple of dinners downtown. Here’s my list of the best restaurants in Charleston, btw!

So Which Resort Is Better, The Sanctuary or The Dunlin?

For me, and for most of the trips my clients are planning, it’s The Sanctuary at Kiawah. Beach over marsh, the polished service I love, an amazing setup for families, and the grand, classic feel of a hotel that’s earned its reputation.

The Dunlin is beautiful and so worth a visit, whether that’s a long lunch at Linnette’s, a sunset cocktail on the marsh, or a night or two to pair a marsh stay with a beach stay on the same trip. Couples and friend groups who want something quiet and laid-back will be very happy there!

If you’d rather be in the city, The Cooper opened on the Charleston harbor in spring 2026 and it’s stunning (with the best pool in Charleston!!). You could also do The Cooper + The Dunlin on one trip if you want a liiiiittle Where-the-Crawdads-Sing Lowcountry energy for a night, then spend the rest of your time downtown. And if you want a more relaxed beach resort at a lower price point, Wild Dunes on Isle of Palms is another favorite (more four-star than five, but the beach is great and it’s built for families).

TL;DR: The Sanctuary at Kiawah vs. The Dunlin

Feature The Sanctuary at Kiawah The Dunlin, Auberge
Setting Directly on the beach On the Kiawah River / marsh
Vibe Traditional, grand, established Modern, curated, design-forward
Service Polished, with twenty years of practice Warm, friendly and laid-back
Best for families? Yes, easily Better suited to couples and adults
Dining Multiple on-site restaurants, including The Ocean Room One signature restaurant, Linnette’s (excellent)
Property size Large, full-resort feel Small and intimate (91 keys total)
Best for Beach trips, families, golfers, multi-gen vacations Couples, design lovers, marsh and nature seekers
Overall winner The Sanctuary Couples, friend trips, a night or two, or a long lunch

How to Book The Sanctuary or The Dunlin With Perks

When you book either hotel through me, you get extra perks on top of your stay at no extra cost. Here’s what’s included at each one:

Booking Your Hotel With Free Jetset Perks

How to Book The Sanctuary at Kiawah with Perks

  • Daily full breakfast for two guests per bedroom
  • $100 resort credit to use during your stay
  • Upgrade on arrival*, plus early check in and late check out* (*if available at check in)

Check Rates + VIP Perks

There is no markup or fee to book hotels with me. Just extra perks for you, and the best rates and exclusive offers, always! You can also see live rates and book yourself on my portal. Password: JETSETTERS.

Booking Your Hotel With Free Jetset Perks

How to Book The Dunlin with Perks

  • Daily full breakfast for two guests per bedroom
  • $100 resort credit to use during your stay
  • Upgrade on arrival*, plus early check in and late check out* (*if available at check in)

Check Rates + VIP Perks

There is no markup or fee to book hotels with me. Just extra perks for you, and the best rates and exclusive offers, always! You can also see live rates and book yourself on my portal. Password: JETSETTERS.

Fill out this inquiry form here and I’ll help you plan your trip, or you can go directly to my travel portal and see my exclusive travel advisor rates and book yourself with all of my perks included! The password is always JETSETTERS (save this page to your bookmarks for future trips!). You can also email me directly at [email protected] and I’ll send you the best rate, all the VIP perks I can get you for your stay, and my personal list of secret Charleston restaurants worth booking.

Related Posts You Might Like

PREV

The Ultimate Charleston Travel Guide

NEXT

What to Wear to Your Bridal Shower : The Best White Bride-to-Be Outfits

WRITTEN BY:

Christina is a leading luxury lifestyle and travel blogger with over 2 million readers. Follow her on instagram @jetsetchristina.

LEAVE A COMMENT